Welcome to Farmer In the Deli
At Farmer In the Deli, we celebrate the art of chopped sandwiches in a casual Brooklyn corner store atmosphere. Our journey began with a passion for delivering exceptionally fresh, made-to-order sandwiches that bring nostalgic flavors to life. Renowned for our signature Chopped Honey Maple Turkey on a hero, each dish is crafted right before your eyes, embracing quality and customer preference. Whether you're indulging in our hearty sandwiches loaded with toppings or experimenting by adding chips for that extra crunch, we promise a fulfilling experience. Join us at 357 Myrtle Ave, where every sandwich encapsulates the warmth of community and the joy of a satisfying meal.
- 357 Myrtle Ave Brooklyn, NY 11205 United States Hotline: (718) 875-9067
Welcome to Farmer In the Deli, a burgeoning gem in Brooklyn that brings a modern twist to the classic deli experience. Located at 357 Myrtle Ave, this vibrant eatery has quickly become renowned for its innovative approach to sandwiches, particularly their viral chopped turkey creations. The atmosphere is casual yet bustling, ideal for a quick lunch break or a late-night snack with friends.
The charm of Farmer In the Deli lies not only in its menu but also in the experience it delivers. As you approach, you may notice a line that often wraps around the store, a testament to its popularity. But fear not, as the wait is part of the adventure. While you wait, you're encouraged to pick up a bag of chips—a secret tip shared by loyal customers who advocate adding them to your sandwich for an extra crunch!
- Signature Sandwiches: The Chopped Honey Maple Turkey on hero bread is a must-try. At just $11.99, this hearty sandwich, loaded with fresh ingredients and a touch of mayo, is known to keep you full for hours. Customers rave about the delightful mix of flavors and textures that come together in each bite.
- Customizable Experience: What truly sets Farmer In the Deli apart is the ability to customize your sandwich. From choosing your protein and toppings to selecting whether you want it on a roll or hero, every customer can create their perfect meal. Options like vegan alternatives and additional toppings enhance the experience further.
- Community Feel: With its friendly staff who passionately craft each sandwich right before your eyes, there's a sense of community that permeates the atmosphere. Regular patrons like Miranda M. express the joy of returning, emphasizing the warm, welcoming vibe whether at 3 AM or mid-afternoon.
Beyond just sandwiches, Farmer In the Deli also offers amenities that make it accessible and enjoyable for everyone, including vegan options, outdoor seating, and even a kid-friendly environment. With ADA-compliant restrooms and closed captioning on TVs, it’s evident that inclusivity is a priority here.
As the sun sets, the deli transforms into a local hotspot for late-night bites, appealing to both hungry locals and adventurous foodies. Comments like Amanda D. highlight how it's worth making the journey to savor the robust flavors packed into each sandwich, and you might even find yourself planning your next visit before you’ve even left!
In conclusion, if you find yourself near Brooklyn, Farmer In the Deli promises not only a meal but an experience filled with deliciousness and community spirit. Remember, the wait might be long, but many agree it’s well worth it for those heavenly chopped sandwiches. Your next favorite deli awaits!

I made a 45 minute walk all the way to try this spot that has gone viral for their chopped turkey sandwiches. When I arrived on a Saturday at 3pm, there was a line that wrapped around the store. While waiting in line, you can grab a bag of chips and drink. The tip is to get a bag of chips to add into your sandwich for some extra flavor and crunch. For my sando, I got the Chopped Honey Maple Turkey on Hero ($11.99) with Pepper Jack Cheese (+$1). Also got all the fix-ins: lettuce, tomato, mayo, salt, pepper, vinegar, and oil. I added half my bag of Utz Crab flavored chips ($2) as well. When I went to pay for it, they even staple my opened bag of chips to "seal" it back for me. It's definitely cool to see them make your sandwich in front of you. Because everything is made to order, the line moves slow thus the long wait times. I ended up waiting 50 minutes. Also, grabbed a bottle of Arizona Green Tea ($1.25) to enjoy my meal over at Fort Green Park. You know how they say you gotta get a bite of everything? This is what makes a chopped cheese so good-- because all the ingredients are well infused together. It might also look like a lot of mayo, but it gives it such a creamy and moist consistency like a chicken/tuna salad. The sandwich is also super filling as I only ate half and then finished the rest for dinner when I got home. Honestly, this sandwich is worth the hype and it's so delicious. The thing is that the wait is so long and it makes me wonder if I could get some similar at another bodega without the wait.

Omg !! This is so freaking delicious. The service was nice at 3am and the food is delicious. The place is also clean with fresh veggies. Will definitely be coming back.

Great spot for chopped deli sandwiches. Line took about 30minutes to get through. I got honey turkey on hero with cheddar cheese, beef bacon, onions, lettuce, salt pepper oil vinegar. It was excellent and worth the wait!

This makes me think of all the happy thoughts from my child hood. This place is just a deli, but for me and my people it is THE deli. The bread is fresh and the sandwich hits every time. I would say if you are anywhere near the Brooklyn Bridge , Manhattan bridge are, if you are any place in Brooklyn, go pass here and wait in line, you won't be disappointed !

This place is iconic. I used to live nearby and never got a chance to try but I've always wanted to try. There's always a line but it moves fast. I love that they make the sandwich in front of you and all ingredients are fresh and to your preference. The big catch 22 is that they don't have any pork/ham/bacon/salami which is terrible for a sandwich shop. My son and I loved our sandwich which was honey turkey, pepper jack, jalopenos, onions lettuce tomatoe mayo oil and vinegar. Sandwich was HUGE and reasonably priced!!

Super delicious chopped sandwiches here! Don't forget to add a bag of chips to chop into it :) I like this location a lot and have tried the chopped sandwich at this location and in midtown. This is definitely a much larger and older deli, which has some chaotic charm. The line moves quickly and the staff are super quick and skilled. I highly recommend getting the toasted hero sandwich and adding some chips. I enjoyed my turkey with cool ranch Doritos, and added some chopped banana peppers and jalapeños as well. It is a bit pricey for sandwiches, and one hero with some additions came out to ~$15. Be warned it is a very heavy sandwich, as the base relies pretty heavily on mayo! I felt full just eating half of the sandwich. Would come again if i'm craving a chopped sandwich!

I have nothing but good things to say about Farmer In the Deli. I used to live close by and go pretty frequently, but despite living further, we still make sure to come by when we can. Walk in and head straight to the back to get in line. Grab some chips while you wait! Chopped, chopped, chopped, they do it best! Be warned, there will likely be a line, even at 2am, but it moves fast. I really love getting tuna, chicken and turkey pastrami but really, you can't go wrong with any of their cuts. Same goes for the cheeses. My favorite thing about this place is they do NOT skimp on portions. You'll need a fork to catch everything as you eat. One thing I really like about these guys is they have an option without any bread, where you get all the goods but in a plastic bowl. If you're cutting down on carbs, it's a great option. Worth the stop, worth the wait, and worth the carbs :)

This place had been in my bucket list forever and we finally made it to NY. The sandwich was worth the trip from Manhattan. It was so good. They have loads of specialty chips on the other side of the store to pair with your sandwich. I got the chopped mesquite turkey and honey mustard. They hand chop the smithereens out of it. The guys making the sandwiches were nice. There is no place to eat inside b/c it's like a corner store. Parking is a bit of a challenge if you drive there and if you go at night there can be some weirdos outside. I'd go again in a "NY minute" next time I'm there!

I'm already trying to plan my next visit to the store! My friend and I were in Brooklyn for the day and I found this location on tiktok because it went viral. We needed to try it before we went back home to Jersey and I'm so happy we did. Yes it is a corner store with your convenient needs but the chopped sandwiches are the star of the show I'm not sure why the chopped Ingredients make the sandwich 10 times better but it was worth the visit. I can't remember the exact price but it varied between $11-$14 and well worth it. You can have it on a hero (long sub bread) or a roll. You can also opt to add chips in your chopped sandwich just hand them the bag. I got the honey maple turkey provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, extra mayo, oil, vinegar, and pepper and a oregano on a hero. Staff was very nice but as you wait in line, make sure to look at the menu so you can know what you want to order to keep up the pace since it does get busy. Overall 10/10!

Came at 11:20 AM on a Sunday and there was a long line; we had our food in hand about 30 mins later. Chopped honey turkey sandwich on hero was absolutely incredible - just get that, don't even think. Chopped tuna on roll was good, but more bland. Stick to the turkey. The guys making the sandwiches were super nice, and their skills are so fun to watch. 5 stars for the chopped turkey alone.